Key Words: If Active Mutual-fund Managers Are Ship Captains, Their Index Rivals Are NASA

That observation and the similes therein are courtesy of market-indexing expert Dave Nadig, chief executive of ETF.com.

The striking quotation appears in a report by MarketWatch’s Ryan Vlastelica appearing Monday in the Wall Street Journal.

The story less memorably but as tellingly quotes Michelle Louie, co-manager of the Vanguard Group fund VFIAX, +0.37% that no less than Warren Buffett pointed to in claiming victory for his wager that a passive S&P fund could outdo a basket of hedge funds over a decade’s time, as having been struck early on by the humility on display among her colleagues, given how much money Vanguard manages. Vanguard’s fund managers, she says, view themselves as nothing more than stewards of clients’ assets.

“Index-fund managers are the underappreciated rock stars of finance,” observes Nadig.

Read on: Why academics are attacking index funds now

Plus: This unique mutual fund charges less than an index fund if it underperforms

RECENT NEWS

When The Wave Turns

Why Retirement Investing Is Moving Towards Resilience Jeremy Grantham’s latest market warnings have revived an old tru... Read more

Gyrostat Capital Management: July Retirement Portfolio Resilience Assessment

The Market Is Currently Presenting an Opportunity to Strengthen Retirement Portfolio Resilienc... Read more

The Invisible Risk That Decides Your Retirement

Why how investors behave matters more than what markets do and what disciplined port... Read more

Gyrostat Capital Management: The Missing Allocation In Retirement Portfolio Construction?

For decades, retirement portfolios have largely been constructed using combinations of growth assets a... Read more

When The Gate Comes Down

A Stress Test Rather Than a ScandalApollo Debt Solutions is not a blow-up story. It is something arguably more instructi... Read more

What If The Investment Industry Is Benchmarking The Wrong Things?

  Investment management is built around benchmarking.  Fund managers compare themselves a... Read more