Deep Dive: Heres How U.S. Brokerage Companies Rank By One Very Important Measure

U.S. brokers that rely on the discount-trading business model are in play, following Charles Schwab’s recent disruptive move to do away with most commissions for online stock trades.

It might be helpful for investors to see which investment banks and broker-dealers have been the best financial performers in recent years. That information is below, based on a screen of data provided by FactSet.

Big broker news

Shares of TD Ameritrade AMTD, +16.92%  were up 17% Thursday, after CNBC first reported the company was working on a deal to be acquired by Schwab SCHW, +7.33%. The Financial Times reported that Schwab was nearing an agreement to pay $25 billion for TD Ameritrade. Shares of Schwab rose 7%.

MarketWatch’s Mark DeCambre shows how the two brokers’ businesses match up.

Another smaller online competitor to Schwab that might have been an acquisition target is E-Trade Financial ETFC, -9.33%, whose stock was down as much as 10% early Thursday.

Read: Two powerful reasons to pass on investing in a combined Charles Schwab-TD Ameritrade

An industry stock screen

A screen of U.S. companies categorized by FactSet as “Investment Banks/Brokers” yields a list of 44 companies. This excludes a large part of the industry.

Financial conglomerates, such as the four biggest U.S. banks (J.P. Morgan Chase JPM, +0.23%, Bank of America BAC, +0.46%, Citigroup C, -0.01% and Wells Fargo WFC, +0.04% ), all of which have investment banking and brokerage operations, are excluded.

Investment-banking giants Goldman Sachs GS, +0.15%  and Morgan Stanley MS, -0.53% are on the list. The list also excludes asset managers and life insurance companies, many of which provide investment management and brokerage services to their customers.

For Schwab, TD Ameritrade and E-Trade, low commissions are nothing new, although Schwab’s recent push to eliminate most online commissions has pushed the entire industry in that direction. These three companies have relied heavily on interest income from deposits that their brokerage customers place in their subsidiary banks. A change in Federal Reserve policy leading to three recent cuts in the federal funds rate has put pressure on this profit center.

All that said, the industry is in flux with the interest-rate challenge, much lower commission revenue, the requirement for very expensive investments in technology and M&A activity. So how can we gauge the group’s performance?

One way is to look at their returns on invested capital (ROIC) over the past five full years. FactSet defines ROIC as a company’s net income divided by total invested capital (total shareholders’ equity and long-term debt). The idea of ROIC is to measure how efficiently a company’s managers use the money they have raised.

We pared the list of 44 companies to 25 with market capitalizations of at least $500 million and for which five full fiscal years of ROIC data were available.

Here they are, sorted by average ROIC over the past five full fiscal years:

Company Ticker Average ROIC - past five full fiscal years Market capitalization ($ million)
Cboe Global Markets Inc. CBOE, -0.14% 48.3% $13,671
MarketAxess Holdings Inc. MKTX, -2.62% 28.0% $15,340
Lazard Ltd. Class A LAZ, -0.59% 24.5% $3,926
Evercore Inc. Class A EVR, -0.55% 19.8% $3,042
Moelis & Co. Class A MC, -1.44% 18.4% $1,642
Houlihan Lokey Inc. Class A HLI, -0.42% 14.8% $1,992
TD Ameritrade Holding Corp. AMTD, +16.92% 14.0% $22,413
Ameriprise Financial Inc. AMP, -0.21% 12.1% $20,066
Charles Schwab Corp. SCHW, +7.33% 11.2% $57,382
Interactive Brokers Group Inc. Class A IBKR, -0.87% 8.6% $3,626
Intercontinental Exchange Inc. ICE, -0.62% 8.4% $52,611
CME Group Inc. Class A CME, -0.56% 8.3% $74,052
LPL Financial Holdings Inc. LPLA, -1.69% 7.9% $7,379
INTL FCStone Inc. INTL, -0.30% 6.9% $755
E-TRADE Financial Corp. ETFC, -9.33% 6.8% $10,361
Virtu Financial Inc. Class A VIRT, +0.60% 6.3% $1,960
Stifel Financial Corp. SF, -0.68% 5.0% $4,203
Nasdaq Inc. NDAQ, -0.91% 4.9% $17,326
B. Riley Financial Inc. RILY, +1.50% 4.2% $770
BGC Partners Inc. Class A BGCP, +0.53% 3.4% $1,708
Morgan Stanley MS, -0.53% 2.7% $79,473
Goldman Sachs Group Inc. GS, +0.15% 2.6% $77,159
Ladenburg Thalmann Financial Services Inc. LTS, +0.00% 2.2% $518
Piper Jaffray Cos. PJC, +0.76% 1.8% $1,137
Jefferies Financial Group Inc. JEF, +1.03% 1.0% $6,090
 Source: FactSet

You can click on the tickers for more about each company, including business profiles, which vary widely.

Leaving the list in the same order, here’s a summary of sell-side analysts’ opinions of the stocks. Price targets and closing prices are as of Nov. 20, which means they are outdated for Schwab and TD Ameritrade, at least.

Company Ticker Share 'buy' ratings Share neutral ratings Share 'sell' ratings Closing price - Nov. 20 Consensus price target Implied 12-month upside potential
Cboe Global Markets Inc. CBOE, -0.14% 40% 53% 7% $123.32 $121.00 -2%
MarketAxess Holdings Inc. MKTX, -2.62% 0% 82% 18% $404.49 $325.00 -20%
Lazard Ltd. Class A LAZ, -0.59% 33% 45% 22% $37.38 $39.50 6%
Evercore Inc. Class A EVR, -0.55% 67% 33% 0% $77.84 $91.38 17%
Moelis & Co. Class A MC, -1.44% 62% 38% 0% $33.27 $39.75 19%
Houlihan Lokey Inc. Class A HLI, -0.42% 62% 38% 0% $47.70 $52.71 11%
TD Ameritrade Holding Corp. AMTD, +16.92% 37% 42% 21% $41.38 $39.43 -5%
Ameriprise Financial Inc. AMP, -0.21% 69% 31% 0% $158.38 $171.20 8%
Charles Schwab Corp. SCHW, +7.33% 42% 47% 11% $44.75 $43.20 -3%
Interactive Brokers Group Inc. Class A IBKR, -0.87% 50% 33% 17% $47.24 $51.40 9%
Intercontinental Exchange Inc. ICE, -0.62% 78% 17% 6% $94.48 $102.82 9%
CME Group Inc. Class A CME, -0.56% 33% 50% 17% $206.64 $216.06 5%
LPL Financial Holdings Inc. LPLA, -1.69% 42% 58% 0% $91.29 $94.11 3%
INTL FCStone Inc. INTL, -0.30% N/A N/A N/A $39.42 N/A N/A
E-TRADE Financial Corp. ETFC, -9.33% 63% 31% 6% $45.86 $44.43 -3%
Virtu Financial Inc. Class A VIRT, +0.60% 50% 50% 0% $16.65 $18.65 12%
Stifel Financial Corp. SF, -0.68% 67% 33% 0% $61.47 $66.40 8%
Nasdaq Inc. NDAQ, -0.91% 41% 47% 12% $105.70 $106.38 1%
B. Riley Financial Inc. RILY, +1.50% N/A N/A N/A $28.59 N/A N/A
BGC Partners Inc. Class A BGCP, +0.53% 100% 0% 0% $5.64 $8.50 51%
Morgan Stanley MS, -0.53% 75% 21% 4% $49.10 $52.80 8%
Goldman Sachs Group Inc. GS, +0.15% 43% 48% 9% $217.91 $236.90 9%
Ladenburg Thalmann Financial Services Inc. LTS, +0.00% N/A N/A N/A $3.48 N/A N/A
Piper Jaffray Cos. PJC, +0.76% 33% 67% 0% $79.18 $85.50 8%
Jefferies Financial Group Inc. JEF, +1.03% 0% 100% 0% $20.31 $22.00 8%
Source: FactSet

Don’t miss: Stock investors may want to hitch a ride with this car-related industry that is set for decades of big growth

Create an email alert for Philip van Doorn’s Deep Dive columns here.

RECENT NEWS

The Penny Drops: Understanding The Complex World Of Small Stock Machinations

Micro-cap stocks, often overlooked by mainstream investors, have recently garnered significant attention due to rising c... Read more

Current Economic Indicators And Consumer Behavior

Consumer spending is a crucial driver of economic growth, accounting for a significant portion of the US GDP. Recently, ... Read more

Skepticism Surrounds Trump's Dollar Devaluation Proposal

Investors and analysts remain skeptical of former President Trump's dollar devaluation plan, citing tax cuts and tariffs... Read more

Financial Markets In Flux After Biden's Exit From Presidential Race

Re-evaluation of ‘Trump trades’ leads to market volatility and strategic shifts.The unexpected withdrawal of Joe Bid... Read more

British Pound Poised For Continued Gains As Wall Street Banks Increase Bets

The British pound is poised for continued gains, with Wall Street banks increasing their bets on sterling's strength. Th... Read more

China's PBoC Cuts Short-Term Rates To Stimulate Economy

In a move to support economic growth, the People's Bank of China (PBoC) has cut its main short-term policy rate for the ... Read more