UK Celebrates 25 Years Of Wasteful, 'underperforming' Government IT Projects

Government IT projects are poorly thought out, often fail to achieve what they're designed to do, and are a waste of taxpayers' money.

Or so the UK's National Audit Office (NAO) has said in a report that lays bare frailties and failures that are so commonplace that few tech pros are likely to be surprised.

The report said the UK has little chance of turning things around because public sector failures are so widespread and deep-rooted, with too few senior government officials armed with the experience and skills to run such schemes.

"Despite 25 years of government strategies and countless attempts to deliver digital business change successfully, our reports show a consistent pattern of underperformance," wrote the NAO in its report "The challenges in implementing digital change" [PDF].

In a bid to try to understand why government projects are plagued by difficulties, the report said: "This underperformance can often be the result of programmes not being sufficiently thought through before key decisions on technology solutions are made. This means that there is a gap between what government intends to achieve and what it delivers to citizens and service users, which wastes taxpayers' money and delays improvements in public services."

The NAO cites a number of examples where government projects have become a costly embarrassment. This includes the Ministry of Justice's criminal electronic ankle tag project that was five years late, cost taxpayers £60m, and was blasted by MPs as a "catastrophic waste of public money."

In the end, the programme used off-the-shelf leg tags that could have been purchased years before and for a fraction of the price. The government's hapless Emergency Services Network – which is designed to offer a new mobile voice and data network for police, ambulance, and fire services – was also singled out by the NAO for being over budget and overdue.

According to the latest NAO figures, the cost of the project has gone from £6.2bn in 2015 to £9.3bn in 2019 – an increase of £3.1bn with a current completion date that is currently seven years behind schedule. From rolling out energy-monitoring smart meters to IT systems designed to handle payments, almost no part of government escapes criticism. /

"When large digital business change programmes run into difficulty, the technology solution is often cast as the primary reason for failure," said the NAO.

"There is rarely a single, isolated reason which causes critical programmes to fail." But the NAO did point the finger at one area of concern:

Asked whether they thought the criticisms were fair, a government spokesperson told El Reg: "Many of the report's recommendations align with this government's strategy for making the UK the world's leading digital government, building on our recently published Declaration on Government Reform.

"Our new digital, data and technology leaders have already introduced many of these recommendations. These include mandatory reporting on outdated IT systems, driving innovation and digital skills across government and plans for data-sharing across online government platforms." ®

RECENT NEWS

Indias Stock Market Surge: A Sectoral Deep Dive And The Modi Effect

In the landscape of global finance, few markets have captivated investor interest quite like India's, particularly again... Read more

Navigating New Horizons: The Entry Of Crypto-ETNs In The UK Market And Its Ripple Effects

In an unprecedented move that marks a significant pivot in the United Kingdom's regulatory approach to digital assets, t... Read more

Navigating The New Frontier: Investing In The Age Of Artificial Intelligence

In recent months, the financial world has witnessed a phenomenon that has reshaped the landscape of investment: the boom... Read more

The Future Of Finance: How Cryptocurrency ETFs Are Changing The Investment Landscape

In an unprecedented move that marked a milestone for the digital currency world, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commis... Read more

Financial Markets Embark On A Resilient Path Amidst Macro-Economic Optimism

Author: Brett Hurll                            &nb... Read more

Nikkei Takes Hit From Japans Vigorous Yen Verbal Intervention, But Yens Gain Lacks Strength

Nikkei tumbled sharply in Asian session today, largely in response to Yen’s rebound late yesterday, which followed s... Read more